| Platinum | Aloha Bakery & Cafe |
| Gold | Gramma's Bakery |
| Silver | Joey's Home Bakery Gluten Free |
| Bronze | Flakowitz Deli • Bakery |
| Top Pick | Annie's Cookie Factory-Pastry |
| Top Pick | Bonnie's Best Bites |
| Top Pick | Cafe Prelude |
| Top Pick | Crumbl Cookies - Cobblestone Commons |
| Top Pick | PR Bakery by Diana |