| Platinum | Josie's Ristorante |
| Gold | Hurricane Alley |
| Silver | Casa Linda |
| Bronze | Two Georges Waterfront Grille |
| Top Pick | Banana Boat |
| Top Pick | El Atico Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Pig-Sty BBQ |
| Top Pick | Prime Catch |
| Top Pick | The Boulevard (Blvd) |
| Top Pick | The Butcher and The Bar |
| Flakowitz Deli • Bakery |